by Nancy Jaffer | May 3, 2024
Saturday’s Kentucky Derby had a stellar line-up, with the likes of $2.3 million yearling purchase Sierra Leone, erratic but brilliant Fierceness and undefeated Japanese star Forever Young, not to mention 17 other contenders. It’s the one day of the year when even people who normally don’t care about horse racing actually do care about horse racing.
But the question was, would the 150th anniversary of the iconic race go down in history as one of the 10 Best Kentucky Derbies?
That’s the title of a new book from the staff and correspondents of The Blood Horse recounting the most memorable runs for the roses. This iconic race, replete with mint juleps and tradition, has many stories to tell.
And yes, you can add another chapter to this volume, and consider changing the name to the 11 Best Kentucky Derbies.
Not only was there a three-way, almost-too-close-to-call at first sight photo finish, but the winning trainer and jockey achieved a memorable double. The day before taking the Derby with Mystik Dan, conditioner Kenny McPeek and rider Brian Hernandez won the Kentucky Oaks with Thorpedo Anna.
In the Derby, Dan nosed out Sierra Leone and Forever Young in a memorable stretch duel. It’s one that won’t soon be forgotten.
What a finish–Sierra Leone, Forever Young and Mystik Dan.
While you’re in the mood to consider Derbies past and present, this book about the best of those races offers not only cherished memories, but also little-known facts abut the most famous Derby winners. Even those of us who really follow racing will discover untold tales and relish reminders of greatness while leafing through its pages.
You can probably guess that the number one story is “The Legend of Big Red” — who else but Secretariat 51 years ago, at the first stop on his way to Triple Crown glory. (That’s our cover photo).
Before the race, he had been syndicated for more than $6 million. Think what that would be in today’s currency. He had a following, he was a star, he rewrote the record book and is probably the one most people think of when they hear the word “racehorse.” He is best known, of course, for clinching that Triple Crown, a feat many thought might never be accomplished again, because it hadn’t happened since 1948 when Citation swept the Derby, Preakness and Belmont trio.
The immortal Secretariat in full gallop forever.
His great rival, Sham, is part of Sec’s story, and deserves deference for his heartbreaking try against the magnificent champion, so let’s not forget him.
Two years before Secretariat, Canonero II also was a sensation. Who would have thought that a colt who sold for $1,200 due to a crooked front leg would have any potential at all? But he wound up in the barn of trainer Juan Arias, who grew up in the slums of Caracas and slept in horse stalls when he got his first full-time job at the track.
Canonero, named after a type of singing group, won his first race in Venezuela and came to Del Mar in the U.S., where he showed promise but bad luck meant he didn’t get sold and went back to South America. The story of how he finally got nominated to the Derby is worth reading, as well as the saga of subsequent trials and tribulations. not to mention his come-from-behind triumph.
Talk about an underdog (underhorse?) He was a real horse of the people.
The “Bad Dream Derby” demonstrated that nightmares can come true, unfortunately. You’ve heard of most of the field in the 1957 Run for the Roses: Bold Ruler, Gallant Man and Round Table. Iron Liege, however was not a household name.
But he wound up the winner when the great jockey, Willie Shoemaker, misread the finish line and stood up in the stirrups aboard Gallant Man, enabling Iron Liege to cross the finish line first. In an eerie twist, Gallant Man’s owner, Ralph Lowe, had a dream two days before the Derby in which that’s exactly what happened.
Trainer John Nerud heard the nightmare story and repeated it to the jockey the night before the Derby, emphasizing to the legendary Shoemaker that he should “Ride past the wire.” When the dream became reality, one has to wonder if the power of suggestion had something to do with the misadventure.
Bill Hartack was all smiles on the way to the winner’s circle aboard Iron Liege. (Skeeets Meadors photo)
There are plenty of other tales worth telling in this volume. It’s as good an accessory for future Derby days as the all-important hat (or that julep). There’s Regret, the first filly to win the Derby in 1915, the long-tailed Whirlaway in 1941 and Alysheba, a determined winner who astounded the crowd when he amazingly recovered from a stumble to take the trophy in 1987. And we can’t forget that longshot of longshots, 2022 winner Rich Strike.
Rich Strike
So who do you like in the 2024 Derby? Will the winner’s story become a conversation piece that morphs into another memorable addition to Derby history? Let’s hope it’s a tale worth telling, and remembering.
If you want the book, click here for a link to buy it.
by Nancy Jaffer | May 1, 2024
The historic Potomac Horse Center in Maryland, which trained generations of horsemen and women, is closing this summer. stating it was unable to renegotiate its 1993 lease.
The 60-acre property is owned by the Maryland-National Capital Parks and Planning Commission (M-NCPPC), which made the renewal contingent on PHC raising $3 million to $5 million to improve the infrastructure, with no assurance that PHC would be permitted to remain on the property, Potomac’s Nancy Novograd announced in a letter explaining the closure.
She explained, “PHC simply cannot ask our clients to pay for and invest in a rapidly deteriorating infrastructure that PHC does not own,” saying the terms of the lease are unsustainable under current economic conditions.”
PHC pays M-NCPPC a monthly base rent for use of the facilities plus a percentage of PHC’s net and gross income.
Additionally, PHC pays for capital improvements, repairs and maintenance of M-NCPPC’s property. Income from the lesson program also goes to veterinary care, farrier services, hay and grain for the horses; utilities, payroll, insurance, farm equipment maintenance, fuel, and tack.
“It has become nonviable for our programs to cover the increasingly higher and higher costs of the rapidly aging infrastructure, let alone allow PHC to build up the $3 million to $5 million required by M-NCPPC toproceed with negotiations,” Nancy said.
The closing is effective July 22, but lessons will continue through June 16.
Asked for comment, Maryland-National Capital Parks and Planning Commission responded that Potomac Horse Center, “a private business, recently notified Montgomery Parks of its intent to end its lease with Montgomery Parks.
“Since its lease began in 1993, PHC has been contractually responsible for all maintenance and capital improvements at the facility. However, structural assessments performed by an outside expert in the fall of 2023 showed major life safety and structural concerns on site.
“Montgomery Parks requested that PHC develop a plan to fund the necessary repairs and maintain a viable equestrian operation. However, PHC instead notified Montgomery Parks of its intent to cease operations and vacate the property. In the near term, Montgomery Parks will take steps to address immediate safety issues on the site,” the statement concluded.
Potomac Horse Center was founded in the late 1950s by F.G. “Stretch” Harting. News that it will not continue was greeted with sorrow by the many friends and graduates of PHC.
In an online posting, Diana Barnes said, “Betty Howett and Colette Stevens came with Porlock Vale experience in the UK, and modeled HorseMasters after the British course of study.”
PHC “Classed-up and stepped up our equine knowledge, `American’ dressage, and style of riding, not to mention improved equine care, both physically and psychologically.”
In another post, Suzanne Crowell stated, “The horse center was particularly important to those of us who had our intro to dressage there. Other than Morven Park there was really nowhere else in the ‘70s. It was instrumental in the accelerated development of the sport in the U.S. The quality of instruction and horses for a large operation was unsurpassed. The everyday clientele were women who worked for a living to support their horse habit.
“I don’t think it’s a coincidence that the job market for women expanded dramatically then, such that women could support themselves with better-paid jobs and had some money left over.”
On June 17, 2024, all assets, including school horses, are available for sale to approved homes, by appointment only. Starting immediately, prospective buyers can try the horses and see everything that is for sale. The horses and equipment needed for daily use will remain on the property through June 16.
However, individuals may immediately purchase all other assets, including surplus tack and farm equipment. PHC will accept cash or certified funds only, but no personal checks and cannot arrange payment plans.
The Potomac Horse Center main number will not be fielding sales calls or making appointments. For inquiries, those interested may call (240) 614-3834.
by Nancy Jaffer | May 4, 2024
This is the weekend it all came down to the wire for the U.S. Olympic dressage ranking list.
Qualifying scores earned at the 3-star TerraNova show near Sarasota, Fla., will help determine which eight candidates head to Europe in the coming months. Competition there will be used in selecting the three-member team for the Paris Olympics.
Several of the horses were latecomers to the quest, joining the contest with new riders just this year. Three are owned by Zen Elite Equestrian Center in Fort Lauderdale.
Endel Ots rides the most celebrated of the three Zen horses, Bohemian, guided to fourth in the 2021 Tokyo Olympics by Cathrine Laudrup-Dufour of Denmark. He capped his campaign with a victory in the Freestyle, where he was marked at 75.670 percent.
Adrienne Lyle’s rides, Helix and Lars van de Hoenderheide, are the others in the Zen trio. Lars won the Special (71.723), with another new pair, Marcus Orlob and Alice Tarjan’s Jane, second on 69.872.
Noting that Saturday was a “blistering hot day,” Adrienne commented that while Lars completed his qualifying criteria for the Olympic short list with his Special victory despite the weather, Helix “did the freestyle just as thunderstorms rolled in.” She said “he found the plants blowing in the wind to be quite scary, but still managed to pull off a podium finish and complete his qualifying criteria.”
Saying it was time for a big sigh of relief after qualifying criteria were completed, Adrienne thanked Zen’s owner, Heidi Humphries, and her own mentor, Debbie McDonald, as well as her grooms.
Kasey Perry-Glass, who had been a team regular with Doublet, now retired, was second in the freestyle on her new ride, Heartbeat W.P. (72.615). Helix, winner of the 3-star Grand Prix on Friday, was third with a score of 72.560 percent.
The Freestyle is a requirement for Olympic candidates, but it doesn’t count in their overall standings. It’s the Grand Prix and the Special, which determines the team medals at the Games. The Freestyle secures individual medals, which are considered less important than team medals in the big picture.
The U.S. Equestrian Federation next week will announce the pairings that go to Europe for observation competitions. The list is likely to include Olympic veteran Steffen Peters, who has been at the top of the rankings with his 2021 Tokyo mount, Suppenkasper. He did not come East for competitions this year, and neither did fellow Californian Anna Buffini, who is also has been near the top of the list with Fiontini.
Among the others in contention in addition to Adrienne, Endel, Marcus and Kasey include Ashley Holzer with Hansel, second in the Grand Prix and fourth in the Freestyle; Katherine Bateson-Chancler with Haute Couture, Sarah Tubman (First Apple) and Anna Marek (Fire Fly), who did not compete at TerraNova but already was qualified.
Click here for TerraNova Grand Prix results
Click here for TerraNova Grand Prix Special results
Click here for TerraNova Freestyle results
by Nancy Jaffer | Apr 28, 2024
Oliver Townend had to come from behind to win the Defender Kentucky 5-star three-day event, but the world’s number one eventer simply did all he could do by riding a perfect show jumping round Sunday on Cooley Rosalent, then waited for the leaders to make mistakes. They did.
Going into the final phase of the event, the top three in the standings were from Britain, with Oliver in third place by a margin of less than a 4-fault knockdown.
After Oliver finished his tour of the course, he just had to wait and watch to see what the others would do.
Oliver and Cooley Rosalent clear the final fence in show jumping. (Photo © 2024 by Nancy Jaffer)
World Champion Yasmin Ingham, who had been standing second on Banzai du Loir, dropped to third along with a rail from an oxer midway through the course designed by Steve Stephens. She finished on 35.6 penalties. Then Olympic medalist Tom McEwen and JL Dublin looked on track to keep the number one spot until the penultimate fence, a Liverpool, where Dubs touched a pole and it fell. That put Tom second with 33.8 penalties and gave the title to Oliver for the fourth time.
Tom McEwen and JL Dublin. (Photo © 2024 by Nancy Jaffer)
“I’m still in shock,” he said at the awards ceremony, where he received the silver trophy from Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear.
The rider earned that prize (and $123,000) at his hundredth 5-star event, an amazing statistic. He is tied with German superstar Michael Jung in the number of Kentuckies that he has won; only the legendary Bruce Davidson did better, with six victories during his heyday at the Kentucky Horse Park.
At first, it seemed that things might not turn out in favor of Oliver.
“I was fairly upset with myself after the dressage,” he said. Mistakes there left him tied for eighth place, and he wasn’t confident of finding a way to claim his usual Kentucky victory.
“I thought it would be a bit depressing going home on that plane having not won,” he mentioned.
“Then I sort of gave myself a kick into gear and thought, `She’s a very good horse.’
“I knew she’s an incredible galloper (her sire jumped 1.60 meters and her dam won the Scottish Midlands Grand National) so there’s no excuse on being too slow.” (Interestingly, Rosalent’s older full brother, Jewelent, was ridden to twenty-ninth place in the Cosequin Lexington 4-star earlier in the day by Phillip Dutton, who was making his fiftieth appearance at Kentucky.)
Oliver explained his strategy for a pleasant plane ride home by saying, “I had a very clear picture in my mind of what I wanted to do and how I wanted to do it. If it was going to be my week, what will be will be. Just do my job and try and look after her for the future and also try and be as competitive as possible.”
Oliver and Cooley Rosalent enter the arena while he was still in shock over his victory. (Photo © 2024 by Nancy Jaffer)
The mare was just one second over the optimum time on cross-country, putting her in that competitive position in show jumping, depending on what Oliver’s rivals did.
Only Oliver and a German Kentucky first-timer, Malin Hansen-Hotopp, fourth on Carlitos Quidditch K, were able to go double-clear in the show jumping. Malin won the James Wofford “On the Rise” award for the best finish by a first time 5-star competitor. Four other riders kept all the rails in place, but wound up collecting time penalties.
The double clear really was an achievement for Cooley Rosalent, who finished the week on a score of 31.8 penalties.
“I couldn’t be more proud of the horse,” said Oliver, noting “she was always special from the word go.”
“We’ve had her since she was four years old,” he said of the 10-year-old Irish-bred gray (his lucky color), a prospect he bought himself, then sold quickly to Diana and Paul Ridgeon. Paul just celebrated his 92d birthday and owned event horses for 45 years, but this was his first victory at the 5-star level.
After winning Great Britain’s Burghley 5-star last September with a former Kentucky victor, Ballaghmor Class, Oliver is now in line to take the $350,000 Rolex Grand Slam if he can win Badminton next month. Only two riders, Pippa Funnell and Michael Jung, have been able to meet that challenge, but Oliver will give it a try on his third attempt.
“The first time, I nearly killed myself trying to win it. The second time I was second at Badminton,” he recalled ruefully.
Tom was philosophical about losing the title when he was so close to getting it.
“Today is one of those things and I’m sure I’ll beat myself up about it, but he’s crazy special,” he said of the horse who is nicknamed Dubs.
“I know on his day, he will wipe the floors clean. It’s exciting coming up to an Olympic year to have put ourselves in a great position.”
Yasmin felt her rail was just an unlucky rub during an otherwise excellent performance by Banzai.
“These things happen for a reason,” she believes, “and I know we’ll come out stronger next time. I’m delighted with him; it’s exciting to be on the podium at a 5-star and it’s a very important year.”
Yes, it could well be that Oliver, Yasmin and Tom will comprise the British team at the Paris Olympics.
Joe Eberhardt, CEO of Jaguar Land Rover North America, toasts a great 5-star with Lauren Nicholson, Tom McEwen, Oliver Townend and Yasmin Ingham. (Photo © 2024 by Nancy Jaffer)
The U.S. national championship went for the third time to Lauren Nicholson, the top American, fifth on the 18-year-old Vermiculus. The horse is owned by Jacqueline Mars, which is particularly nice because the event is presented by MARS Equestrian.
Top U.S. rider Lauren Nicholson on Vermiculus. (Photo © 2024 by Nancy Jaffer)
“We came feeling a touch rusty,” said Lauren, explaining the horse “hasn’t had a proper big outing” since 2022.
She was pleased that she was “able to deliver what he deserved to get on the day.”
After cross-country, the highest-placed U.S. rider was Mia Farley on Phelps, standing fifth with one of only two double-clear trips in the second phase.
Mia had many rooters among fans in the packed Rolex Arena, because Phelps is a Kentucky-bred thoroughbred who was sold for a dollar. But the fairytale didn’t have a storybook ending in the 5-star. Phelps demonstrated that show jumping is his weakness in the Maryland 5-star last year, and this time, the problem was evident immediately. He dropped a rail at the first fence, then toppled three more before he finished his round. Mia wound up an unlucky thirteenth.
Click here for Defender 5-star results
by Nancy Jaffer | Apr 27, 2024
Elisabeth Halliday, who had shared top billing after dressage in the Cosequin Lexington 4-star at the Kentucky Horse Park, found herself alone at the top of the chart with Miks Master C after a trip over the testing cross-country course on Saturday.
Mickey, third in the 5-star last year, had only 3.2 time penalties over a route that saw five eliminations and eight retirements.
Noting Mick “is a pretty keen horse on cross-country,” Elisabeth pointed out, “he’s a very good jumper and very careful. Although he was strong between the fences, he was very thoughtful and very organized in all the combinations. I was very thrilled with him.”
Elisabeth Halliday and Miks Master C. (Photo © 2024 by Nancy Jaffer)
Liz was busy in the 4-star, riding two other horses, Cooley Quicksilver, who is seventh and Shanroe Cooley, eighth.
The lone double-clear of the day over Derek di Grazia’s route came from Will Coleman and his rising star Diabolo, just 0.7 penalties back of Elisabeth’s 29.2-penalty mark.
Going into cross-country day, Elisabeth’s score was the same as that of Lucienne Bellissimo on DYRI, so they were tied. But Lucienne had problems at the five-part combination that was fence six—along with 20 other competitors and on her other horse, Tremanton, as well. She sank to thirty-first on 20 penalties for a refusal and 25.6 time penalties with DYRI.
I asked Will why so many riders had trouble at the combination. I don’t remember one cross-country obstacle getting quite that many victims, at least recently.
“It was a clever question, because it didn’t walk intimidating at all,” Will replied.
“I thought the `in’ to the coffin was pretty close to 5-star (difficulty). A lot of the horses just looked they didn’t quite know where to look. There is a lot going on there, it’s early in the course. Most people that had trouble, it looks like to me they didn’t get their horse back in what you’d say was a proper coffin canter. If you jump in either too fast or too out of balance…it can be harder for them to recover over the ditch.”
Will, like Elisabeth, said he was thrilled with his mount.
“I do have a lot of belief in the horse. We are still sort of getting to know each other. I think he’s got the qualities of being a winning horse. He’s not quite there yet. It’s kind of what we’re working towards. This was a step in that direction. I thought it was a good track and he actually enjoyed the whole experience; you know, the people and that Kentucky atmosphere.”
Will Coleman and Diabolo. (Photo © 2024 by Nancy Jaffer)
Boyd Martin finished third with Commando 3 (30.1) and just ahead of Will’s other horse, the veteran Off the Record (30.9). In fifth place, Pan American Games individual gold medalist Caroline Pamukcu on HSH Blake has 32.5 penalties, tying for fifth with Boyd on Federman B. So it’s a close race, with less than a rail’s difference among that group.
“I think we’re all on very good show jumpers, the top four or five horses are very good show jumpers and good show jumping riders,” said Boyd.
click here for 4-star results
by Nancy Jaffer | Apr 27, 2024
The odds might seem to be against the U.S. repeating its 2023 victory in the 5-star Defender Kentucky Three-Day Event.
Last year, Tamie Smith on Mai Baum became the first American to win the competition since 2008. This year, the top U.S. rider after cross-country is Mia Farley, but there is something standing between her and the trophy—what could well be the British team for the Paris Olympics. They are occupying first through third places before Sunday’s show jumping finale. And right behind them is Monica Spencer of New Zealand.
Mia is fifth with Phelps, the thoroughbred that her trainer, David O’Connor, bought for a dollar (which he still owes the seller, I believe). She has 33.8 penalties, to 28.6 for the leader, Tom McEwen on JL Dublin. That means Tom can topple a rail and still finish ahead of Mia (but not his compatriots, World Champion Yasmin Ingham, second on 31.6 penalties with Banzai du Loir and world number one Oliver Townend, third with 31.8 on Cooley Rosalent in his landmark one hundredth 5-star). Tom also does not have one-rail edge over Monica, fourth on 31.9 with Artist.
Kentucky 5-star leader Tom McEwen of Britain on JL Dublin at the Head of the Lake. (Photo © 2024 by Nancy Jaffer)
But Mia already has achieved a distinction. She was one of only two riders to go double clear today over Derek di Grazia’s beautiful but demanding course within the 11-minute, 14-second optimum time. (Germany’s Christoph Waller on D’Accord FRH was the other, now standing sixth with 34 penalties.) But even beyond that, this was the second time Mia had gone double-clear in a 5-star, and she’s only been in two, having debuted at the level in the 2023 Maryland event.
How rare is that record? No less an authority than EquiRatings said that of the more than 1,000 horses who completed a 5-star over the last 15 years, only 37 have managed a double-clear in their first two 5-star outings.
Mia knocked two flags during her trip around the course, and while flag issues can stick a rider with a 15-penalty burden, a review of the videotape revealed no violation.
Knocked flags were no problem for Mia Farley and Phelps. (Photo © 2024 by Nancy Jaffer)
Phelps dropped two places in the Maryland standings due to knockdowns in the show jumping there. Mia thinks this time could be different.
“We’ve been working hard at it this year. Show jumping is his weaker phase, but we’ll see tomorrow,” she explained. “No matter what, I’ll try to be happy with today and hope his training at home comes through.”
There were 37,953 fans at the Kentucky Horse Park on cross-country day (to read about the 4-star, click here or go to the second feature on the main page) and many of them seemed to be cheering on Phelps, a son of famed stallion Tiznow. After all Phelps is a Kentucky-bred. Kentuckians love thoroughbreds (don’t forget the state is the home of the Kentucky Derby).
Mia appreciates a thoroughbred’s attributes, noting that previously she rode a warmblood who was apt to start running out of gas at the end of cross-country.
With thoroughbreds, bred both for speed and endurance, “at the end of the course, if you ask them to go, they have it.”
That means a rider has a lot of options
At the very least, Mia is well-situated to be the top U.S. competitor, which would give her the national championship title
Tom, the rider who EquiRatings projected to be the likely winner, said “Realistically for me, the question was before me what I know the horse can do. That’s what we try to deliver on the day.”
He cautiously took two long routes that resulted in 4 time penalties, but he had enough margin from the score of Dubs’ lovely dressage test to keep his standing at the top of the results.
The issue gets more complicated because he’s trying to prove his worth for the Olympic team. Ditto Yasmin and Oliver. The Olympics allows only three riders on a team, though an alternate can come on board in certain circumstances during the competition.
Yasmin Ingham and Banzai du Loir. (Photo © 2024 by Nancy Jaffer)
Oliver was asked if the 10-year-old Rosalent would be his choice for an Olympic mount, as opposed to one of his other horses.
“I’d like to think she’s definitely in the mix,” Oliver responded.
“She’s been to Maryland and here. She’s proved that she copes with the crowd, she’s proved that she copes with quick tracks. She’s definitely on an upwards trajectory in terms of the way she’s finding the competitions. Fingers crossed, it’s not my decision on this, but I’d very much like to get there on any horse,” said Oliver, who is going to Badminton on another horse.
Oliver Townend and Cooley Rosalent. (Photo © 2024 by Nancy Jaffer)
There were two horse falls during the 5-star. Canada’s Lisa Marie Ferguson took a tumble when the 18-year-old Honor Me went down, and Philip Dutton hit the turf after a tired Quasi Cool was asked to leave a bit too long to the last fence and chipped in. Both horse and rider were fine, and Azure was sent to his stall for rest and fluids.
Boyd Martin retired On Cue (eleventh after dressage) partway through the course, feeling that she wasn’t herself and didn’t like the ground.
Click here for the 5-star results
