Time flies—except when you’re watching 12 hours worth of the Dover Saddlery/USEF Hunt Seat Medal Finals. Do you really need to have 208 starters for this marathon at the Pennsylvania National Horse Show?
It’s tough enough for anyone to win without having to deal with an endurance contest on top of testing courses.
When the top 25 were sifted out on Sunday after a 7 a.m. start, they came back for a second round; then the top six did another test involving lots of counter-canter before the ribbons were pinned shortly after 7 p.m.
In the end, Carlee McCutcheon, who finished the first round in 14th place, was an obvious winner. Riding Chacco Star—who was named the best horse in the class—she nailed the counter-canter options and made them look smooth and precise. The test also included a trot fence and a hand-gallop, to which she really committed. Her halt after the final fence was practically textbook.
Carlee McCutcheon and Chacco Star. (Photo courtesy of USEF)
The Texan stood second on the final callback list behind Tessa Downey, who went last in the test, but had a counter-canter issue and wound up fifth. Tessa, who won the equitation title at Capital Challenge earlier this month, is trained at Ashland by Ken and Emily Smith and Peter Pletcher.
Jack Towell, who judged the class with Timmy Kees, said, “The quality of the riders is unbelievable, but also the quality of these horses. These horses are amazing animals, amazing. They’ve got the stride, the scope – it blows me away just watching them. Not that these kids don’t ride great, but you’re only as good as your horse.”
“The vehicles are the catalyst,” noted Timmy.
“The level of instruction, the caliber of the horses and the capability of the kids – it’s all amazing to watch. I’ve seen it for a long time, and it just keeps getting better and better.”
As Carlee noted about her mount of two years, owned by Kennedy McCauley, “The harder the course is, the better he is.”
Noah Nelson, a student of the Smiths, was reserve champion while Val Renihan’s student, Kate Hagerty, finished third, ahead of Olivia Sweetnam, coached by her mother, Ali. Someone to keep an eye on is Cody Rego, who finished sixth under the tutelage of Missy Clark, John Brennan and Maggie Gampfer. He is from Bermuda and has an impressively competent style. Unfortunately, he toppled a rail in the test.
Carlee McCutcheon and her team at the Pennsylvania National.
A member of the famous reining family, Carlee does as well in a western saddle as she does in an English saddle, but show jumping is the fame she is pursuing for her career now. Her mother, Mandy McQuay McCutcheon, won the USET ‘s Rolex Talent Derby as a teen.
Carlee was the reserve champion last weekend at the Platinum Performance/USEF Show Jumping Talent Search Finals East, and it was obvious then that she was destined for a huge win in the not-too-distant future. Like eight days later.
In the time flies category, she was coached by Max Amaya and T.J. O’Mara of Stonehenge. Wasn’t it just a couple of years ago that T.J. was winning the Medal? Nope, it was 2016. Time flies.
“It was very emotional for me,” said T.J.
“My sister, [Meg O’Mara] won this in 2012, and then I won in 2016; Carlee was one of my first equitation kids that I’ve gotten the pleasure to train. She came to us two years ago. I helped her here at the Medal Final in 2021, and each year she’s gotten better and better with it.”
Click here for the results