Thoroughbreds are few and far between at the upper ranks of three-day eventing, ever since the steeplechase and roads and tracks elements were eliminated from the sport’s prestige competitions after 2005.
With the departure of the long format, where endurance was key, the heart exhibited by thoroughbreds on cross-country suddenly wasn’t quite as important as the ability to perform first-rate dressage and show jumping.
It was good news for the Europeans, who had long wanted to sell their warmbloods for eventing, but it meant that the horses once synonymous with the game were out of favor. The top 10 in the 5-star division at last weekend’s Land Rover Kentucky Three-Day Event included everything from a Hanoverian (eventual winner fischerChipmunk FRH) to a Selle Francais and several Holsteiners, but only one thoroughbred in that top group.
That was Phillip Dutton’s well-bred off-the-track mount, Sea of Clouds by Malibu Moon (A.P. Indy X Mr. Prospector). Sea of Clouds is owned by Sheikh Fahad Al Thani of Qatar, who raced him, along with Graham Motion who trained him at the track and his wife, Anita Motion, as well as Phillip and his wife, Evie Dutton. He started just twice in races, then made his debut in FEI competition during 2017.
Phillip Dutton and Sea of Clouds going cross-country at Kentucky. (Photo © 2022 by Nancy Jaffer)
There were eight other thoroughbreds in the 5-star field of 45 who appeared for the first horse inspection. They finished 11th, 20th, 21st, 23d and 30th, in last place. Three were eliminated, two on cross-country and one in the final horse inspection.
Sea of Clouds was tied for 31st in dressage, but moved up to seventh after cross-country, one of just three horses who made the optimum time over Derek di Grazia’s exacting track. (Phillip has had 11 cross-country clears at Kentucky between 2008 and this year, more than any other rider.)
The other horses double clear on the 5-star cross-country were Michael Jung’s mount, fisherChipmunk, a Hanoverian who has a heavy dose of thoroughbred in his bloodlines, and Boyd Martin’s ride Tsetserleg, a Trakehner by Windfall whose dam, Wundermaedel, was a thoroughbred off the track.
The 11-year-old Sea of Clouds dropped three places in the final Kentucky 5-star standings after two knockdowns in the show jumping finale. His 10th-place finish was the highest for a thoroughbred in the 5-star.
Sea of Clouds going cross-country at the 2019 Jersey Fresh International Three-Day Event in the 4-sart Long division. (Photo © 2021 by Nancy Jaffer)
His performance encapsulates the pluses and minuses of a thoroughbred at the highest level of eventing. At Britain’s Badminton 5-star, which gets under way today, only 3.5 percent of the starters are thoroughbreds. Phillip is riding Z, a Zangersheide, at that competition.
So after Kentucky wrapped up, I asked Phillip if thoroughbreds still have a place in the sport at the highest level.
“The right one does,” he said. As he has noted, they are bred for galloping, a key for cross-country success where making the optimum time is so important, as time penalties can often be decisive in the placings.
But even so, “the dressage and show jumping have gotten so difficult that horses are getting bred especially for it,” Phillip pointed out, then added, “You can’t get a better cross-country horse than the thoroughbred.”
Sea of Clouds in the dressage at Kentucky. (Photo © 2022 by Nancy Jaffer)
The trick, he said, is to find one who can move well enough for the dressage. That isn’t something in which Sea of Clous is a standout, and at Kentucky, he “got a little tense” as Phillip put it and kicked up his heels in the canter work to the point where the spectators went, “Oooh.”
(Amanda Pottinger of New Zealand found a thoroughbred who can handle the dressage. On the first day of the Badminton Horse Trials May 5, she stood seventh on a very respectable 25.9 penalties with the 16-year-old Just Kidding. He is by 2000 Kentucky Derby winner Fusaichi Pegasus.)
If you think back to all the great thoroughbred jumpers (remember Idle Dice and Jet Run?), that phase shouldn’t be an issue.
In addition to his 10th-place ribbon, Sea of Clouds won the Thoroughbred Incentive Program award at Kentucky.
Oh, and in case you’re wondering, a sea of clouds is an overcast layer of clouds, as viewed from above. Great name.
