Seven horses. That’s how many rides Olympic eventer Caroline Martin Pamukcu had at the Essex Horse Trials on Sunday.
Or if you really want to dig into the numbers, you could call it 21 rides, because, of course, she had to compete in three phases — dressage, cross-country and show-jumping — on each of her mounts.
She finished first, second, fourth and seventh in Open Preliminary, the highest-level division offered by the event at Moorland Farm in Far Hills, N.J., home of October’s Far Hills Race Meeting.
Caroline Pamukcu and She’s the One, Open Preliminary winner
In Open Novice, she was second, third and fourth, behind winner Sophia Middleburg.
Then she headed home to Pennsylvania to get in a little more riding while it was still light.
Oh, and she’s also a mother. Caroline’s 18-month-old daughter, Blake, is named after her Olympic equine partner.
Nothing can slow down Caroline, except the case of Covid she caught earlier this spring.
So what’s her secret, how does she keep going at that pace?
“It’s not really a secret. It’s just hard work,” she revealed.
“I wake up every morning four to five days a week at 4:45. My sleep-in days are 7 a.m. wake-up. I try to go to the gym five days a week.”
And after that she rides, so there are days that run from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m.
Explaining her drive, she said, “I really, really want to be a top, top rider. I’ve got to push myself so I can be.” (I thought she already was!) In her view, though, that includes winning a 5-star event for the first time.
So why come to Essex? It was missing the sport’s other big names.
Essex has a great history and once was a “must” stop for high-level eventers. Founded in 1968, it vanished after 1998, came back in a big way in 2017 and then struggled a bit. The solution for continued survival involved ending the multi-day approach and making it into a one-day event last year, along with the determination of Marilyn Payne and her organizing committee to keep it going.
Essex enjoys the comfortable feel of a local competition, but has wonderful ambience, getting great crowds tailgating around the water obstacle on the challenging course designed by Morgan Rowsell in the heart of the beautiful Somerset Hills.
It was an ideal destination for Caroline to give a couple of her top horses “a quiet run before the 4-star long at Bromont (Quebec)” next week.
They are She’s the One, who led wire-to-wire to win the Open Prelim on 30.5 penalties, and HSH Double Sixteen, second in the division with 32.
Caroline Pamukcu and HSH Double Sixteen, second in the Open Preliminary.
“You have quite a bit of atmosphere here, so it’s really good for them,” she said, noting that applies even to a “seasoned competitor” such as Double Sixteen.
It also suited her “really exciting young horses” who got useful experience.
“This time of year, you focus on the next generation,” she said.
Calling Essex “amazing,” she stressed the importance of having an event like that at this level.
“This is the biggest crowd we’ll have all spring, besides Kentucky (the Lexington 5-star in April.)
“It’s so great for the horses. A huge shout-out to Morgan, he really made the course flow super-well. Being able to do dressage and show jump on the grass, you need the experience to teach your horses to push off this surface. The ground was foot-perfect. You would want to do your horse’s last gallop before the Olympic Games on this footing.
“There are so many good people keeping this event alive. I really hope some of the other top riders come out here,” she continued, but noted the discipline’s schedule has been so busy that this time of year, many riders would like a short break.
Trainer Michael Pendleton, who won the Open Training with Gravitas (33 penalties) and his student, Lily Barlow, the Preliminary Rider winner on Sportsfield Kan Do (44) came from Aiken S.C., for Essex.
Michael Pendleton and Gravitas, Open Training winner.
“The course was awesome. It’s good to come up here and get on the hills and have some decorated jumps,” Michael said.
The long drive to get to Essex was “worth it,” he said.
Lily commented about her horse, “This is his first Preliminary, it was kind of a big step up for him, but he was awesome.”
At home, “We see the same shows all the time, so this was so good for them. This is my first time here and I love it,” she said, commenting particularly on the crowd.
“It’s so cool to go through the water and have people cheering. You don’t see it much in the South unless you’re going to a really big event. And if it’s a really big event, you don’t want it to be the first time your horse sees that.” (a crowd).
Essex didn’t give awards for rider endurance, but if they did, Holly Payne Caravella certainly was in the running.
Holly, the daughter of Marilyn Payne, won the Open Modified wire-to-wire on Princess Candy with a score of 25.7 penalties from dressage unsullied by any errors in the other phases. She rode her mother’s Rock Me Mama to second place with 25.9, also unsullied.
Holly Payne and Rock Me Mama in the stadium jumping phase of Open Modified.
With her Essex duties, Marilyn obviously, was too busy to ride her own horse, although she has placed first in a division there previously.
“She wanted to move her up,” said Holly about her mother’s thoughts on what Rock Me Mama should do.
Candy is an Irish import bought by Olivia Ford as a 5-year-old.
The mare doesn’t have a princessy attitude, instead living up to the second part of her name.
“She’s really sweet,” explained Holly.
Holly Payne Caravella and Open Modified winner Princess Candy.
Her win was definitely an achievement.
“It’s really hard here, especially the water jump, because of all the tailgaters, the atmosphere. Both of the girls have done two Modifieds, this is their third and this is the hardest one. When I walked the course, I was like `Two jumps in the water?’
“A lot of times at that level, you might just have one jump in the water and that’s hard enough.”
Indeed, several horses in that division and Modfied Rider took issue with having to jump the second of a pair of “lobster traps” in the pond.
Asked why she thought more top riders didn’t come to Essex, Hollly said the eventing schedule is very full now. She noted that riders who want to ride in the FEI long events need to qualify at FEI short events, and Essex is not FEI, so that is a factor.
But for those who want to give horses mileage and enjoy something reminiscent of the days when people were in it for the sport without worrying about qualifying for this and that, or trying to be selected for a team, Essex has a great deal to offer — and for spectators as well
The trade fair more than doubled in size from last year. Sarah Thomann, who works in the office at Redfield Farm in Hunterdon County, got a booth from which to sell her bejeweled browbands, halters and belts (or take orders for custom work) because, “I thought it was great to be part of a community event that was local. A lot of people stopped, more so for custom orders,” she reported.
Essex Horse Trials merch was a big seller in the trade fair.
Purina was on hand with a giveaway for riders who could guess their horse’s weight, a number confirmed when the animal stepped on a scale.
The prize was a saddle pad, supplements and other useful goodies.
Winner Janina Parmelee correctly guessed that her U.S.-bred Redfield Mikke, a German riding pony, weighed in at “1,050 pounds exactly.”
Janina is the owner of the personality-plus bay gelding, who came through Caroline Martin Pamukcu’s sales program. She rides him in dressage, so her friend, Kylie Stangle, was the one who guided him to victory over 13 other entries in the Novice Rider competition. Kylie keeps the ribbon; Janina, a fashion designer, keeps the other prizes.
Janina bought Mikke five years ago when she wanted a horse that could “do a little bit of everything.” She and Mikke are in Marilyn Payne’s training program.
Dr. Jennifer Gill, a nutrition consultant for Purina, said “We love supporting the local community and we just love riders and supporting them in what they do, they work so hard.”
She said there was good participation in the weight-guess program, but noted, “It usually surprises people how different it is from what they might think.”
Marilyn, who has ridden or judged at Essex every year since it started, is dedicated to having an event where people interested in participating in the sport can “get in the door,” and hosting “a lot of spectators and introduce them to what eventing is, because most of them don’t know. I just didn’t want to let it die. It’s amazing the people behind me, because I couldn’t do this myself. Everyone does it because they love it.”
Heather Gilette, president of the ground jury, who first rode at Essex in 1987, is donating her services to help insure that Essex survives.
“It’s part of our culture and our neighborhood,” she emphasized.”
“It’s sort of in your blood and part of your system if you’ve grown up eventing anywhere in the area. It’s a fixture.”
“Even if they’re not riders, everybody wants to be a part of it,” commented Marilyn.
So what was her verdict for the 2026 version of the event?
“The weather was perfect. It was super.”
click here for results
