Congratulations to Kim Herslow for winning the 3-star Intermediate I and I-1 Freestyle during Dressage at Devon in 2021.
Wait–what? 2021? This is not a news flash that got buried by mistake nearly two years ago.
This month, Ailene Cascio, owner of Herslow’s mount, Elvis HI, finally received the redistributed prize money for her horse’s 2021 victories at the Pennsylvania show. Herslow had finished second in both competitions, but was elevated to first place when Cesar Parra on Belle Ami was disqualified and ordered to return the prize money and ribbons.
Cesar Parra and Belle Ami at the 2021 Dressage at Devon. (Photo © 2021 by Nancy Jaffer)
That was part of an agreement with the FEI (international equestrian federation) connected to an “Equine Controlled Medication Rule Violation (Presence of Benzocaine in the Horse’s Sample).”
Belle Ami also tested positive for caffeine, but Parra’s caffeine matter and two unrelated cases in show jumping were closed, according to an FEI report on 12 Atypical Findings (ATFs). The FEI stated, “The majority (9 out of 12) of the ATFs involved Prohibited Substances which are generally considered more likely to have been ingested by horses for a purpose other than the enhancement of sport performance, for example, through a contaminated feed source.”
Parra thought the presence of caffeine might be attributed to a driver who had spilled a Starbucks order on the horse’s hay. He pointed out a stimulant like caffeine is counter-intuitive, because mounts should be calm in the arena.
A member of the 2015 U.S. gold medal dressage team at the Pan American Games in Toronto, Herslow finished second in the Prix St. Georges at Devon 2021 behind Donna Gatchell and Reflection. Parra came in third with Belle Ami and was disqualified from that class as well.
Herslow missed being able to ride the I-1 and I-1 Freestyle victory passes on Elvis in front of the crowd at the prestigious autumn show (Parra got that honor), because of course, medication disqualifications are never immediate. What made it worse for her, however, was the long delay in receiving the redistributed prize money.
“I was wronged. I feel there is no accountability,” said Herslow, who now owns Elvis in partnership with Cascio.
She only found out about the disqualification because Steven Tarshis, a Flemington, N.J., attorney who is representing Belle Ami’s owner in an unrelated lawsuit involving Parra, called to tell her he had learned of it after he sought an appraisal of the mare for his client.
Kim Herslow and Elvis HI at Devon 2021. (Photo © 2021 by Nancy Jaffer)
When he had his expert check with the FEI on the horse’s show history for the appraisal, he was told about the Devon disqualification. Since Herslow is a friend and a client, Tarshis passed the information on to her.
The FEI provided Tarshis with a copy of a notification it sent to Parra on December 9, 2021, advising the rider that he had been disqualified from the classes in which he competed on the mare at the show two months earlier.
The FEI communication stated that if Parra accepted the penalty of returning all the prize money ($2,890), the ribbons and other items he received in the three classes at Devon, paid a fine of 1,500 Swiss Francs and costs of 1,000 Swiss Francs to the FEI, he would not be suspended. Parra noted he didn’t want to dispute the finding of a “minimal” amount of Benzocaine, and the FEI said it could “fast-track” the matter if he complied with the penalty. He mentioned he had never been sanctioned by the FEI, and once the process was completed, “I totally forgot about it” in terms of returning prize money to the show.
He said he never got anything from USEF that would have reminded him, “but I don’t think it was anybody’s bad intention.
“Time went by and then we remembered. So I called Monica (Fitzgerald, the Devon show secretary).” At first she said she didn’t know anything about it, then told him, “Let me find out.”
When she did, “I just sent them a check and that was it,” commented Parra, who rode on the 2011 U.S. dressage gold medal Pan Am team in Guadalajara, Mexico. He also competed for his native Colombia at the 2004 Olympics in Athens, as well as on its silver medal team in the 1999 Pan American Games in Winnipeg.
Belle Ami’s owner was concerned that her horse had a sore in her mouth and shouldn’t go to Dressage at Devon, according to Tarshis, but Parra said the sore had cleared up prior to the show. He mentioned the benzocaine was in a remedy one of his grooms sprayed on her arm for a skin irritation, and he wasn’t sure how it entered the horse’s system. He suggested it could have gotten on a thermometer when the horse’s temperature was taken, but emphasized there was no ulterior motive.
“What’s the point to win something if you are cheating? It doesn’t make any sense,” said Parra.
He believed the groom was using Dermoplast, listed generically as benzocaine. According to the Mayo Clinic website, benzocaine, available without a prescription, is used to relieve pain and irritation caused by sore throat, sore mouth or canker sores. On the container, Dermoplast is recommended for minor cuts, scrapes and burns.
When Tarshis contacted the U.S. Equestrian Federation about Parra’s status, he said, “At first, they told me that they had no record of his disqualification. I made them look further, and they were able to confirm that they had been notified. The next day, the USEF show records that are listed on their website (were) revised to show Cesar’s disqualification.”
Herslow, who runs Upper Creek Farm in Stockton, N.J., pointed out, “No one has called me to apologize that it took almost two years to get this reconciled.”
Elvis HI and Kim Herslow in the Dixon Oval at Devon. (Photo © 2021 by Nancy Jaffer)
That happened, “only because it came up from a separate lawsuit. My owner was short over $1,000 ($1,065), which finally just got paid from Devon.” The show also is sending ribbons and replica trophies to Herslow and will have her name engraved on the perpetual trophy.
“This shouldn’t have taken so long,” a USEF spokesperson stated about the prize money redistribution, maintaining the show had been notified about the disqualification in a timely manner.
Anne Moss, the show’s president, knew nothing of the Parra situation when she took the post in 2022. But as soon as she learned that money needed to be redistributed, the wheels went into motion. She confirmed the show received a check for the prize money from Parra this month.
Until last week, when this website asked him about the disqualification, Parra’s own website, Dr Cesar Parra Dressage Sport (he had been a practicing dentist, hence the dr. title) still listed Belle Ami as the winner of the I-1 and I-1 Freestyle. That information was deleted by last weekend. Parra said he personally does not work on the website and it is handled by an employe.