The odds might seem to be against the U.S. repeating its 2023 victory in the 5-star Defender Kentucky Three-Day Event.
Last year, Tamie Smith on Mai Baum became the first American to win the competition since 2008. This year, the top U.S. rider after cross-country is Mia Farley, but there is something standing between her and the trophy—what could well be the British team for the Paris Olympics. They are occupying first through third places before Sunday’s show jumping finale. And right behind them is Monica Spencer of New Zealand.
Mia is fifth with Phelps, the thoroughbred that her trainer, David O’Connor, bought for a dollar (which he still owes the seller, I believe). She has 33.8 penalties, to 28.6 for the leader, Tom McEwen on JL Dublin. That means Tom can topple a rail and still finish ahead of Mia (but not his compatriots, World Champion Yasmin Ingham, second on 31.6 penalties with Banzai du Loir and world number one Oliver Townend, third with 31.8 on Cooley Rosalent in his landmark one hundredth 5-star). Tom also does not have one-rail edge over Monica, fourth on 31.9 with Artist.
Kentucky 5-star leader Tom McEwen of Britain on JL Dublin at the Head of the Lake. (Photo © 2024 by Nancy Jaffer)
But Mia already has achieved a distinction. She was one of only two riders to go double clear today over Derek di Grazia’s beautiful but demanding course within the 11-minute, 14-second optimum time. (Germany’s Christoph Waller on D’Accord FRH was the other, now standing sixth with 34 penalties.) But even beyond that, this was the second time Mia had gone double-clear in a 5-star, and she’s only been in two, having debuted at the level in the 2023 Maryland event.
How rare is that record? No less an authority than EquiRatings said that of the more than 1,000 horses who completed a 5-star over the last 15 years, only 37 have managed a double-clear in their first two 5-star outings.
Mia knocked two flags during her trip around the course, and while flag issues can stick a rider with a 15-penalty burden, a review of the videotape revealed no violation.
Knocked flags were no problem for Mia Farley and Phelps. (Photo © 2024 by Nancy Jaffer)
Phelps dropped two places in the Maryland standings due to knockdowns in the show jumping there. Mia thinks this time could be different.
“We’ve been working hard at it this year. Show jumping is his weaker phase, but we’ll see tomorrow,” she explained. “No matter what, I’ll try to be happy with today and hope his training at home comes through.”
There were 37,953 fans at the Kentucky Horse Park on cross-country day (to read about the 4-star, click here or go to the second feature on the main page) and many of them seemed to be cheering on Phelps, a son of famed stallion Tiznow. After all Phelps is a Kentucky-bred. Kentuckians love thoroughbreds (don’t forget the state is the home of the Kentucky Derby).
Mia appreciates a thoroughbred’s attributes, noting that previously she rode a warmblood who was apt to start running out of gas at the end of cross-country.
With thoroughbreds, bred both for speed and endurance, “at the end of the course, if you ask them to go, they have it.”
That means a rider has a lot of options
At the very least, Mia is well-situated to be the top U.S. competitor, which would give her the national championship title
Tom, the rider who EquiRatings projected to be the likely winner, said “Realistically for me, the question was before me what I know the horse can do. That’s what we try to deliver on the day.”
He cautiously took two long routes that resulted in 4 time penalties, but he had enough margin from the score of Dubs’ lovely dressage test to keep his standing at the top of the results.
The issue gets more complicated because he’s trying to prove his worth for the Olympic team. Ditto Yasmin and Oliver. The Olympics allows only three riders on a team, though an alternate can come on board in certain circumstances during the competition.
Yasmin Ingham and Banzai du Loir. (Photo © 2024 by Nancy Jaffer)
Oliver was asked if the 10-year-old Rosalent would be his choice for an Olympic mount, as opposed to one of his other horses.
“I’d like to think she’s definitely in the mix,” Oliver responded.
“She’s been to Maryland and here. She’s proved that she copes with the crowd, she’s proved that she copes with quick tracks. She’s definitely on an upwards trajectory in terms of the way she’s finding the competitions. Fingers crossed, it’s not my decision on this, but I’d very much like to get there on any horse,” said Oliver, who is going to Badminton on another horse.
Oliver Townend and Cooley Rosalent. (Photo © 2024 by Nancy Jaffer)
There were two horse falls during the 5-star. Canada’s Lisa Marie Ferguson took a tumble when the 18-year-old Honor Me went down, and Philip Dutton hit the turf after a tired Quasi Cool was asked to leave a bit too long to the last fence and chipped in. Both horse and rider were fine, and Azure was sent to his stall for rest and fluids.
Boyd Martin retired On Cue (eleventh after dressage) partway through the course, feeling that she wasn’t herself and didn’t like the ground.
Click here for the 5-star results